An Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) may be a great alternative for business owners who are contemplating liquidity, succession planning and legacy. There are many types of ownership transition strategies, including:
-
- Selling internally to an ESOP, a management group, or a combination of the two
- Selling the company to a competitor or private equity firm
- Merging with another company
- Going public
- Transferring the business to family
- Liquidating
SES ESOP Strategies can help you explore the feasibility of these options and help you find the right fit for your strategic goals.
What is an ESOP Feasibility Study?
An ESOP feasibility study, or transaction analysis, is an important first step in providing shareholders and key advisors with the information they need to make an informed decision and determine if an ESOP is the right liquidity and succession strategy to achieve the desired goals and outcomes.
What is the Purpose of an ESOP Feasibility Study?
An ESOP feasibility study analyzes key concerns, such as:
- Anticipated range of value of the company for ESOP transaction purposes
- Transaction structure(s) for the purchase of shares from shareholders
- Available finance and funding structures to acquire company stock from shareholders
- Debt capacity, including availability and key terms and conditions of potential senior and/or seller
financing to be provided in the transaction - Impact of an ESOP transaction on the company’s cash flow and financial position
- Analysis of sellers’ tax-effected cash flow resulting from the sale of company stock and the financing of that sale
- Management team and executive compensation issues, including the use of stock appreciation rights or other synthetic equity
- Structure of the internal loan between the company and the ESOP
- Comparison of S Corp vs. C Corp transaction structures
Along with assessing the impact of the ESOP on its shareholders, the sponsoring company, the employees and the ESOP itself, the company’s debt borrowing capacity and future cash flows must be considered. The goal is to create a roadmap to develop a transaction structure and price that is fair to the company’s shareholders, workable for an ESOP transaction and manageable for the company itself while also complying with the ESOP requirements mandated by the Internal Revenue Service and the U.S. Department of Labor.
What Makes a Good Candidate For an ESOP?
Employee stock ownership plans can be structured to operate successfully with both public and private companies of all sizes. Flexible plan design allows ESOPs to align with owner succession planning, management team goals and business operation.
The ideal private company candidate will meet most of the following criteria:
Profitable
Closely held companies with stable cash flow and reliable profitability are good candidates for an employee stock ownership plan as they can support a leveraged transaction, fund ongoing plan design and contribute to meaningful employee benefits.
From a financing standpoint, the long-term success of an ESOP depends on the company’s ability to generate earnings and manage cash flow to meet debt repayment and share repurchase obligations.
Consistent earnings also help to steadily grow company share value for employee owners, support the role of ESOP trustees and fund participants’ retirement plan benefits over time. As a general matter, companies with less than $1 million in adjusted pre-tax earnings (EBITDA) may not be a good fit given the administrative and fiduciary costs of establishing and maintaining the plan.
Minimum Number of 20 Employees
As a general guideline, companies with fewer than 20 employees may not be a strong fit for an ESOP due to compliance testing requirements that vary by transaction structure. However, this is not a bright-line threshold and should be evaluated on a case-by-case basis.
Trusting Environment
An ESOP is most effective when employees and management are aligned around the company’s long-term success and the teamwork needed to achieve it. A culture of accountability and engagement across the organization helps support productivity and growth of an ESOP over time. Strong alignment can also reduce turnover and encourage employees to investment in the company’s growth.
How We Can Help With Your Feasibility Study
Selling all or part of a business is one of the most consequential decisions you will make as a business owner. It requires balancing financial goals with employee impact and the level of control you want to retain during the transition.
Our team works closely with business owners, management teams and other stakeholders to perform an ESOP feasibility analysis to determine if a company is a good candidate for an ESOP. Through this process, the team can evaluate liquidity, financing options, cash flow, executive compensation and transaction structure to develop a tailored ESOP transaction.
We also assess how your company’s operations, culture and succession planning goals align with becoming an ESOP company, and how plan design and repurchase obligations will be managed. ESOP trustees play a key role in overseeing this process to ensure the transaction is fair and sustainable.
How a Feasibility Study Can Identify Elements of a Successful ESOP
The feasibility study helps to identify the following key elements of a successful employee stock ownership plan:
- Business valuation for an ESOP transaction
- ESOP transaction structure and plan design
- Financing and funding approach, including leveraged or non-leveraged structures
- Debt capacity, including senior financing or seller notes
- Projected cash flow and the company’s financial position in an ESOP structure
- Analysis to determine seller proceeds on both a pre- and post-tax basis
- Management team and executive compensation issues
- Structure of the internal loan between the company and the ESOP
- Comparison of S Corp and C Corp transaction structures
- Employee benefit design and long-term sustainability within the ESOP structure
This process provides business owners of closely held companies with a clear, data-driven view of whether an ESOP is the right fit for their succession planning strategy.
Find Out If Your Business Is a Good Candidate for an ESOP With a Feasibility Study
ESOPs can be a strong succession planning option for many closely held companies and business owners, but the strongest candidates share a few key traits, including:
- Consistent profitability and stable cash flow
- 20 to 25+ employees to support plan costs and deliver meaningful employee benefits
- Trusting environment
- Ownership culture of accountability and engagement across the organization
- Management team committed to long-term value creation
SES ESOP Strategies helps business owners conduct in-depth ESOP transaction analyses—going beyond a basic feasibility study—to determine if an employee stock ownership plan is the right fit for their companies.
Contact Us to Request a Feasibility Study